For economists and lawyers
Economists and lawyers move between the academy and policy, and both inherit a national-wealth ledger that books only what contracts record — assembled in bespoke, closed workbooks you can cite but cannot rebuild.
In the United States the same people write the theory and the rules. Economists and lawyers move from the faculty to the Treasury, the Fed, the agencies, the courts and the international financial institutions, and back. Both carry the same ledger with them: national accounts that book what contracts record, claim-rights and their correlative duties, and treat the rest of what a society owns as off the page.
Economists
You know the citation problem in this literature: a wealth-accounting table shows up in a paper, the appendix gestures at a methodology, and the assembly — which agency series, which year, which judgment call filled which gap — stays inside someone’s private workbook. You can build on the headline number, not on its construction.
FAND treats the pipeline as the deliverable. The balance-sheet identity — what an economy owns, what it owes, and the trust infrastructure in between — is documented as a 12-stage build with a source agency directory behind every term. It continues published work: John O’Connor pioneered the World Bank’s wealth metrics in Monitoring Environmental Progress (1995), which the Bank still updates as The Changing Wealth of Nations. The comparison page sets out where FAND now diverges: four types of capital rather than three, an identity closed to the cent, cross-border positions carried gross. On reproduction, the honest state: the pipeline is documented (builder scripts, a SHA-256 audit trail, a manifest pinning each release’s source snapshot), but the public repository is not live yet, and the replication page says so. The convergence essay shows the payoff: a finding built entirely on one normalized panel, with its self-checks shown, that a reviewer can interrogate because the panel is the one you would extend.
Lawyers
In 1913 Wesley Hohfeld showed that every legal relation is one of eight positions in four correlative pairs: right and duty, liberty and no-right, power and liability, immunity and disability.1 The System of National Accounts reads only the first pair. FAND draws its accounting boundary on Hohfeld’s full map, and its fourth type of capital, Other Substantive Rights, is what the other three pairs hold. That is not a new move in economics: John R. Commons built institutional economics on Hohfeld’s correlatives in Legal Foundations of Capitalism.2 Tamara Lothian’s Law and the Wealth of Nations makes the modern case from the law side: the legal arrangements of finance and the market are not fixed, and can be remade to serve production and democracy.3 FAND supplies the ledger that case needs — what the governed hold beyond their claims.
The founders’ hybrid
Law and economics is often told as a postwar invention of the University of Chicago, with Hayek’s circle as its origin story.4 The hybrid is far older. Adam Smith taught the Wealth of Nations inside his lectures on jurisprudence,5 Hayek himself took his first doctorate in law, and the American republic was founded by lawyer-proprietors. About half of the 56 signers of the Declaration of Independence were lawyers, and so were more than half of those who signed the Constitution.6 Many also ran farms, plantations, shops and counting houses, so law and economy were one practice for them, and some — Franklin, Jefferson — were polymaths in the full sense. (Two of the most consequential, Washington and Franklin, were not lawyers.)
Their great graft was a hybrid of republic and democracy: the imported scion of a republic, with its standing rules and offices, grafted onto the hardy native stock of settler self-government. Law stands to economics as the republic stood to the democracy in that hybrid. One sets the standing frame of rights, duties, powers and immunities; the other is the many deciding for themselves, by exchange as by vote, within it. Neither thrives cut from the other. To credit Chicago with inventing the hybrid is to credit the gardener who pruned the tree with planting it.
They wrote the Enumeration into Article I as a ledger of consent. The same clause counted enslaved people as three-fifths of a person, people in whom others held claim-rights while they themselves held almost none. That is the Hohfeldian failure in its starkest form, and the reason a ledger of rights has to read every column.
Start with the framework’s accounting boundary and the glossary, read the comparison if your work touches the CWoN lineage, then the replication page before deciding what you would rebuild.
Footnotes
-
Wesley Newcomb Hohfeld, “Some Fundamental Legal Conceptions as Applied in Judicial Reasoning,” Yale Law Journal 23 (1913): 16–59. ↩
-
John R. Commons, Legal Foundations of Capitalism (Macmillan, 1924). ↩
-
Tamara Lothian, Law and the Wealth of Nations: Finance, Prosperity, and Democracy (Columbia University Press, 2017). ↩
-
Rob Van Horn and Philip Mirowski, “The Rise of the Chicago School of Economics and the Birth of Neoliberalism,” in Philip Mirowski and Dieter Plehwe, eds., The Road from Mont Pèlerin (Harvard University Press, 2009). ↩
-
Adam Smith, Lectures on Jurisprudence (1762–63 and 1766), ed. R. L. Meek, D. D. Raphael and P. G. Stein (Oxford University Press, 1978). ↩
-
Counts vary with how “lawyer” is defined in an era when most read law rather than attended law school: from 22 to 30 of the 56 signers of the Declaration, and 21 of the 39 signers of the Constitution. See “The Role of Lawyers in the American Revolution,” Religious Educator 12, no. 2 (2011), Brigham Young University Religious Studies Center. ↩
Start here
-
FAND Explorer Prototype
An early integrated navigator across the balance-sheet items — ordinal and Q-score only at this stage. Useful for seeing the full item set before you decide what to extend.
-
Featured essay — The Ledger of Consent and the 1890 Break
The founders' Enumeration as a ledger of consent, and how the punch card narrowed it to what a machine could tabulate.
-
In Products — World Tables by topic
Start with the free tables; next, the replication package and matched model testing, or one of the Directions for Further Work.
Related pages
- Hohfeld's missing columns — The accounting boundary: eight jural positions, of which the System of National Accounts reads one pair.
- OG-011 — Hohfeldian Law and Economics — The operational guideline: every balance-sheet entry is classified by its jural position before its accounting treatment is decided.
- How the Pieces Fit — Five questions, one argument: what counts, how it is valued, at whose prices, who keeps the record, and what follows.
- Intractable Index Number Problems — The price side: why FAND publishes value at current prices, converts by the Atlas method rather than at PPP, and uses one deflator.
- Capacity, Not Uptake — How a measure of rights should behave if a right is a liberty — tested at the US county.
- Take-Off in Convergence Terms — A convergence-literature finding built entirely on the balance-sheet panel: 42 of 46 Bretton-Woods-era peakers have since fallen back below 30% of the US frontier.
- FAND vs CWoN — comparative analysis — Four types of capital or three: where FAND's identity diverges from the World Bank's Changing Wealth of Nations, and why it matters for anyone extending either.
- Replication package — The 12-stage pipeline and its current reproduction status — read this before you decide what to build on.
- Source agency directory — Every input series, by agency, table, and vintage — the raw material any extension starts from.
- Glossary — The conceptual vocabulary — CommonWealth, NUSAP, the Hohfeldian framework — defined with provenance and cross-references.
Talk to us about your research or your brief
The replication package is documented, but the public code repository is not live yet — that status is stated plainly on the replication page rather than papered over. If you want to reproduce, extend, or rely on a specific result, in a paper or in a policy brief, tell us which one and we will point you at the sources and the exact steps.