Four Types of Capital or Three

FAND and the Changing Wealth of Nations, compared.

Really: Look Beyond GDP video

Really: Look Beyond GDP. Nine minutes on why decades of "Beyond GDP" advocacy kept adjusting the income statement instead of building a balance sheet, and how FAND widens the asset boundary past what the national accounts can see.

Download the slides (PowerPoint, 0.3 MB), with the narration in the speaker notes.

John pioneered the World Bank’s wealth metrics in Monitoring Environmental Progress (MEP, 1995).1 MEP’s balance sheet had four types of capital: produced assets, natural capital, human resources, and a fourth that MEP called Social Infrastructure. The Bank’s current wealth accounts, The Changing Wealth of Nations (CWoN), count three: produced, natural and human capital, plus net foreign assets.2 FAND keeps MEP’s four. It calls the fourth type Other Substantive Rights.

Four types or three

CWoN builds wealth from the bottom up. It values each class of asset separately and adds them up. What it cannot list as an object does not exist on its balance sheet. Hicks would call that the Materialist view.3

FAND starts from the top. CommonWealth is what a nation’s income is worth as a going concern: Atlas GNI, capitalized. FAND then values the same three types CWoN does. What the governed recognize and value beyond those three, such as the rule of law, institutional trust and the room to act, is the fourth type, Other Substantive Rights. An economy needs some minimum of these rights to function, so FAND never books them below 20 percent of CommonWealth. Where they fall short of that floor, the gap is booked as Deferred Maintenance of Trust and priced as a risk premium. Net Worth then adds what nonresidents owe residents and subtracts what residents owe them. See the balance sheet.

The fourth type changes the story the data tell about the Bank’s own borrowers. Between 1995 and 2020, the middle-income economies, home to 5.4 billion people, closed much of the distance to High income in income. FAND Net Worth moves with that income. CWoN wealth falls behind it.

Three panels, Low income, Lower middle income and Upper middle income, each showing per capita values as a percent of High income from 1995 to 2020 for Atlas GNI, FAND Net Worth and CWoN wealth. Lower middle income in 2020: FAND 5.2 percent, Atlas GNI 4.8 percent, CWoN 3.5 percent. Upper middle income in 2020: FAND 22.2 percent, Atlas GNI 20.1 percent, CWoN 14.2 percent. Low income in 2020: CWoN 2.2 percent, Atlas GNI 1.7 percent, FAND 1.6 percent.
Each line is a group total per capita as a percent of the High income total per capita, in current US dollars. In the upper-middle-income group, income rose from 6 to 20 percent of High income. FAND Net Worth rose with it, to 22 percent. CWoN wealth reached 14 percent. The lower-middle-income group tells the same story at a smaller scale. In the low-income group the three lines rise by similar amounts. Groups follow the World Bank's current classification, and the same 139 economies appear in every year and every line. Sources: World Bank, The Changing Wealth of Nations 2024 (national comprehensive wealth); FAND national Net Worth; World Bank Atlas GNI.

With three types, wealth is a pile of parts, and a society’s institutions can neither add to it nor subtract from it. Publicly traded firms dropped that kind of accounting long ago, once it was clear that a business held for use can be worth more or less than its separable assets. With four types, the gap between what an economy yields and what its parts account for is information. It shows where rights are building wealth, and where trust is being run down and has to be repaid.

How best to measure the three both share

Both systems value produced assets, natural capital and human resources. They differ on how.

ComponentCWoNFAND
Produced assetsPerpetual inventory from Penn World Table investment seriesAnchored to official national balance sheets (OECD) where published; perpetual inventory extends them to 200+ economies
Natural capitalResource rents over asset life, each component deflated separately to constant dollarsEight branches valued at market prices in current dollars; one general deflator for all components
Human resourcesLifetime earnings of the working population, from household surveysA function of schooling and life expectancy, the split John made for MEP in 1992, fitted across 200+ economies and 75 years
Coverage151 countries, 1995–2020200+ economies, 1950–2025

Prices. Separate deflators for each component wash out the relative prices that carry the signal. Gold and oil are a clear case. Over 1995–2020, the market ratio moved about fivefold, from roughly 9 to 43 barrels of oil per ounce of gold. The ratio implied by CWoN’s constant-dollar values stayed between about 31 and 45. For the full comparison, see the working paper.

Accuracy against precision. CWoN’s components are precise where household surveys and detailed rents exist. FAND trades some of that precision for accuracy. Every component sums to a total anchored to published national income, so an error in one component cannot disappear: it shows up in the fourth type, where it can be seen. Timeliness is part of accuracy too. A measure that ends in 2020 cannot say much about 2025. A quarter century of data, 1995–2020, is less than a third of the eighty years the Bretton Woods institutions have been at work. For 46 nations, home to 1.4 billion people, the best years against the United States came in the par-value era of 1950–71, which a series starting in 1995 never sees. See Take-Off in Convergence Terms.

In fairness to CWoN: a component-by-component account does not depend on a capitalization rate, and it does not let the errors of three estimates pile up in a fourth. FAND’s answer is to test that fourth type against outside evidence, as in Capacity, Not Uptake, and to score its parts directly as the data allow.

Below the nation

The same balance sheet runs down to US states, US counties and Global Roots, where most of the governed actually meet their government.

Footnotes

  1. World Bank, Monitoring Environmental Progress: A Report on Work in Progress (Washington, DC, 1995). ↩

  2. World Bank, The Changing Wealth of Nations 2024, data for 151 countries, 1995–2020. ↩

  3. John Hicks, “Capital Controversies: Ancient and Modern,” American Economic Review 64, no. 2 (1974): 307–316. ↩