Capacity, Not Uptake

Evidence essay · Experimental badge

Rights come first. A legal system may limit its purview to claim-rights and the duties that answer them: what a court will enforce, what the national accounts will book. The governed do not limit themselves that way. “The enumeration in the Constitution, of certain rights, shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people.”1 A balance sheet that counts only enumerated claims supposes it can limit human action to them. That rarely works.

The fourth type of capital

FAND books what the governed recognize and value beyond enforceable claims as its fourth type of capital, Other Substantive Rights. Examples include the room to organize, to speak, to move and to start something. An economy cannot run on less than some minimum of these rights, so FAND never books them below 20 percent of CommonWealth. Where the estimate falls short of that floor, the gap is booked as Deferred Maintenance of Trust, which lenders price as a risk premium. The two indicators are read together. See the balance sheet.

What a right is, and what it is not

Hohfeld’s analysis separates a claim-right, which someone else has a duty to honor, from a liberty, the room to act whether or not you use it.2 Most of what the governed value sits on the liberty side. A liberty is a capacity, not a behavior. So a measure of rights, if it is any good, should follow the opportunity to take part, and it need not follow how much people actually take part.

The test, in US counties

We took FAND’s figure for Other Substantive Rights net of Deferred Maintenance of Trust down to about 3,043 US counties. Then we ranked it against the indicators researchers already use for “social capital.” The result split in two, as the concept predicts.

Opportunity to take part: aligned (positive).

IndicatorρWhat it measures
Nonprofit density (NCCS 2014)+0.38organized civic infrastructure
MapAgora “take action”+0.20channels available to act
MapAgora “volunteer”+0.10chances to volunteer
MapAgora events / membership+0.04 to +0.08chances to associate

Taking part: inverse (negative).

IndicatorρWhat it measures
Social clustering (Chetty Atlas)−0.30how tightly people actually cluster
JEC Social Capital Index−0.23composite of realized participation
Civic organizations (Chetty)−0.21realized membership
Association density and voting (Goetz)negativerealized turnout and joining

Counties rich in the opportunity to act are not the counties where people cluster and join the most. A behavior count would read that as a contradiction. A rights measure predicts it, because having room to act does not mean everyone acts. One plausible reading is that where formal channels are thin, people lean harder on tight networks of their own.

Why it matters

A measure that behaves the way its concept says it should is the strongest evidence an early indicator can offer. It also points to the next step. Each component of Other Substantive Rights can be recognized and scored directly against its place on the balance sheet, instead of being inferred from what is left over. Recognition comes before valuation.

Experimental: county figures are rank correlations (Spearman ρ) with wide margins of error. They show a structural pattern, not a ranking of places.

Sources: Kim, de Vries & Han (2025), MapAgora; Rupasingha, Goetz & Freshwater, NERCRD; Chetty et al., Social Capital Atlas (2022); Joint Economic Committee, Social Capital Project (2018). FAND county build.

← back to The Evidence

Footnotes

  1. U.S. Constitution, Amendment IX (1791). ↩

  2. Wesley Newcomb Hohfeld, “Some Fundamental Legal Conceptions as Applied in Judicial Reasoning,” Yale Law Journal 23 (1913): 16–59. ↩