FAND's switches
Where FAND keeps two defensible choices side by side, and why.
Every wealth account makes choices that reasonable people make differently: which prices to use, how to value people, how to fill the last year before every country reports. Most accounts pick one setting and leave the alternatives in a technical annex. Ratings and composite indexes do the same with their weights.
FAND does it differently. Where the evidence does not settle a choice, FAND keeps both settings as a switch, sets a default, and shows which numbers move when the switch is flipped. A reader can then see whether a conclusion depends on a choice or survives it. Narrowing the settings to one is a matter for the people who use the numbers to agree on, weighing evidence and opinion together (weight of discussion), not something any single analyst should decide for them.
Today the switches are set in FAND’s builds and exhibits. Reader-facing toggles are being built into the FAND app.
The switches
1. Currentness: as reported, or current. Sources report late and unevenly, so the most recent years are ragged. A group total that is missing its late reporters is a partial sum, not a total. As reported shows the ragged edge raw. Current (the default) completes each group’s series by assuming non-reporters moved with their group (the OconEco Gap Filler, OGF), and marks every completed value. Country pages keep true gaps as gaps.
2. Prices: one deflator, or one per component. FAND values everything in current dollars and makes it “real” with a single general deflator, so the relative prices between oil, gold, land and labor stay visible. The alternative deflates each component by its own index to constant dollars, as the World Bank’s Changing Wealth of Nations (CWoN) does. Set to the second option, FAND’s natural capital and produced assets can be read on CWoN’s basis. See Four Types of Capital or Three.
3. Human resources: schooling and life expectancy, or lifetime earnings. FAND values human resources from schooling and life expectancy, fitted across 200+ economies from 1950. CWoN uses lifetime earnings (the Jorgenson–Fraumeni method), which needs household surveys of earnings by age, sex and schooling. Those surveys are its high price: they confine the method to the countries and years the surveys reach, 151 countries from 1995 in CWoN’s latest edition. FAND carries lifetime earnings as a cross-check where the surveys exist. How FAND estimates human resources →
4. The floor under Other Substantive Rights. FAND never books Other Substantive Rights below 20 percent of CommonWealth. Any shortfall is booked as Deferred Maintenance of Trust and priced as a risk premium. The 20 percent is the premium’s one stipulated parameter, so FAND shows it as a sensitivity. A floor much higher, near 45 percent, would put even the United States on the floor and leave no capital market for the premium to price.
5. The premium’s yardsticks. Four settings change how the risk premium is summarized, not how it is measured:
- weights, by people or by GDP;
- the comparator, the high-income average or its lowest-income members, and sovereign ratings or traded default swaps;
- the base rate, fixed or the prevailing US rate;
- World Bank lending eligibility, as it is today or as it stood each year.
6. Who counts as resident. Cross-border workers and the income they send home can be booked by the residence rule of the balance of payments (BPM6), or on a commensurate basis that follows the same people and income on both sides of a border. Neither is settled, so FAND keeps both.
Why it matters
Ratings, composite indexes and the wealth accounts behind them each pick one setting per choice. Those settings move large sums: lending allocations, capital requirements, the terms on which poorer members borrow. A switch makes the choice visible and its consequences checkable. When a result holds under every setting, it is robust. When it flips, the flip is the information.
Related reading
- The balance sheet: the identity every switch leaves intact.
- How we grade what we publish: completed and estimated values carry lower scores.
- Operational Guidelines: the rules each default follows.